Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Nuclear Energy News .




WAR REPORT
Is the Nobel Peace Prize losing some of its prestige?
by Staff Writers
Oslo (AFP) Dec 07, 2012


Often described as the most prestigious award in the world, the Nobel Peace Prize risks losing some of its lustre because of the prize committee's unexpected and controversial choices of late, some observers warn.

The European Union, which will pick up the 2012 prize at a formal ceremony in Oslo on Monday, is the latest in a string of such laureates.

"Farce", "scandal", "joke", "ridiculous" and "absurd": those are a few of the terms detractors have used to brand the Norwegian Nobel Committee's picks in recent years, mixed in with the usual praise heaped on Oslo.

"Some of the recent choices have tarnished the reputation of the award and cast doubt on the legitimacy of the Norwegian Nobel Committee," a US journalist and expert on the prize, Scott London, told AFP.

"The peace prize is no stranger to controversy ... but I think the blunders and bad choices have become more common in recent years," he added.

After the bombshell announcement that US President Barack Obama was to win the 2009 prize in his first year in office, the prize committee this year raised eyebrows again by giving the nod to a crisis-ridden European Union plagued by divisions.

The choice prompted some unexpected swipes, including from previous laureates.

In between those two jaw-dropping laureates came the 2010 winner, jailed Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo, who was generally hailed with the exception of Beijing which called the committee "clowns".

But the 2011 edition, which honoured three women, also courted controversy, with laureate Liberian activist Leymah Gbowee accusing her co-laureate, Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, of corruption and nepotism.

For Norwegian lawyer Fredrik Heffermehl, author of the book "The Nobel Peace Prize: What Nobel Really Wanted" and a relentless critic of the committee, the damage has been done.

"The prize doesn't go to those who work for a global peace order made up of demilitarised nations, and it has lost its credibility, both legally and morally, by obstructing and sabotaging for years that which Nobel stood for," he told AFP.

Much of the criticism about the peace prize is aimed at the prize committee's chairman, Thorbjoern Jagland.

Since his arrival in 2009, he is believed to have influenced the four other members of the committee, with the help of its longstanding secretary, Geir Lundestad, who does not have the right to vote but whose voice carries much weight.

By straying from the instructions outlined in the 1895 will of Swedish philanthropist and inventor Alfred Nobel that created the prize, "they have in reality stolen the prize", Heffermehl claimed.

So is the Nobel discredited?

"The prize? Probably not," responded Antoine Jacob, the author of a book on the history of the Nobel prizes.

"It's still highly-awaited each year and is well-anchored in a tradition that has had its highs and survived its lows," he said.

"That said, the credibility of the committee ... has eroded since 2009 in the eyes of those who follow world affairs closely," he explained.

Jagland "wants to use the prize as a tool for his personal convictions, because he is deeply convinced that he is in the right", Jacob said.

Some have called for a reform of the committee, whose members are usually former politicians designated by the Norwegian parliament.

Among the proposals have been to open the committee to less political figures -- to further increase its independence -- and to include people more specialised in foreign affairs, possibly even foreigners.

The head of the Peace Research Institute of Oslo, Kristian Berg Harpviken, said he favoured such a reform even though he is not concerned about the Nobel's prestige.

"The controversial choices are not what threatens the status of the Nobel Prize the most. The threat comes from the consensual prizes, the rather boring ones," he said.

"The Nobel Peace Prize is so well-anchored as the most prestigious prize in the world that it can survive a good dose of controversy," he said.

.


Related Links






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








WAR REPORT
Britain to press EU partners to amend Syria arms embargo
London (AFP) Dec 06, 2012
Britain will press its European partners next week to amend the arms embargo on Syria to allow them to provide weapons to rebels fighting the regime, Europe minister David Lidington said Thursday. "Having successfully amended the EU arms embargo (and sanctions package) by setting a three-month renewal period, we will make fresh arguments in support of amending the arms embargo ahead of the M ... read more


WAR REPORT
Plastic packaging industry is moving towards completely bio-based products

Gases from Grasses

Garbage bug may help lower the cost of biofuel

Tiny algae shed light on photosynthesis as a dynamic property

WAR REPORT
Flexible solar cells could be in clothing

German's solar ovens make sunbaked tortillas in Mexico

British firm to build 'Africa's biggest solar plant'

The Future Looks Bright: ONR, Marines Eye Solar Energy

WAR REPORT
Brazil advances wind power development

US Navy, DoD, Developer Announce Wind Farm Agreement

Britain: Higher energy bills 'reasonable'

Areva commits to Scotland turbine plant

WAR REPORT
S. America upbeat on energy growth in 2013

Making sustainability policies sustainable

Need for clean energy 'more urgent than ever': IEA

Japan's Hitachi, Mitsubishi Heavy to merge power units

WAR REPORT
Vietnam breaks up anti-China rally, arrests protesters

Four Chinese ships in disputed waters: Japan

Canada approves two energy takeovers worth $20 bn

US extends exemptions for Asian powers to Iran oil sanctions

WAR REPORT
Astronomers discover and 'weigh' infant solar system

Search for Life Suggests Solar Systems More Habitable than Ours

Do missing Jupiters mean massive comet belts?

Brown Dwarfs May Grow Rocky Planets

WAR REPORT
New ship will make Russia superpower on sea

Northrop Grumman to Supply Navigation Systems for Indian Coast Guard Vessels

China conducts first landing on aircraft carrier

India says to get Soviet-era aircraft carrier in 2013

WAR REPORT
NASA to send new rover to Mars in 2020

Safe Driving on Mars

Ancient Mars May Have Captured Enormous Floodwaters

NASA Announces Multi-Year Mars Program With New Rover In 2020




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement